Three young pastors with backgrounds as college athletes now lead some of Conroe’s largest congregations. Jesse Payne, Seth Saathoff, and John Wayne McMann are infusing their churches with energy, vision, and a shared dedication to community growth.
Three pastors in their thirties are reviving some of the city's largest congregations in Conroe. Each pastor brings a distinctive combination of faith, athletic heritage, and vision for growth. W. Conroe Baptist Church, First Presbyterian Church of Conroe, and First Methodist Conroe are under the leadership of Jesse Payne, Seth Saathoff, and John Wayne McMann, all former collegiate athletes. Each of them underwent a personal transformation during their college years, leading them to pursue a career in ministry.
Seth Saathoff, 33, a former football player at McMurry University, discovered his vocation following a sports injury. He pursued ministry under the guidance of a pastor in Abilene and ultimately obtained a divinity degree from Princeton Theological Seminary. Saathoff is the pastor of the First Presbyterian Church of Conroe and is eager to establish a home with his family and provide service to the congregation of 500.
In his early 20s, Jesse Payne, 35, a former baseball player at the University of Texas at Arlington, was inspired to pursue a career in ministry. In April, he assumed the senior pastor role at West Conroe Baptist Church, succeeding Jay Gross, who had served as the church's pastor for 25 years. Payne, who resides in Conroe with his wife and three daughters, is enthusiastic about the region's expansion and is anxious to become involved in the community.
In 2022, John Wayne McMann, 38, was appointed as the leading pastor of First Methodist Conroe. McMann, a former soccer player at Rhodes College, was profoundly affected by the support of his faith during family difficulties. He was motivated to pursue a career in ministry and is currently the pastor of a congregation of 2,500. He is enthusiastic about the prospect of creating a legacy with his family.
These youthful pastors represent a new generation of faith leadership in Conroe. They are united in their dedication to community growth and connection.
